How to Sell Your Sports Card Collection

We travel for large sports card collections and typically stay within a 350–400 mile driving radius of Columbus, OH. This includes areas in Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Kentucky, Tennessee, West Virginia, Virginia, and parts of North Carolina.

To help us review your collection efficiently, please provide as much detail as possible:

  • An overview of your sports card collection, including key cards, notable players, and complete sets.

  • Your estimated value of the collection.

  • A spreadsheet or organized list of cards.

This information helps us prepare a fair and accurate offer.

See Where We Travel To Buy

Shipping Options & Buying Process

We can also provide a pre-paid FedEx shipping label for items that are small enough to be mailed. We simply ask that you reach out when you’re seriously considering selling. We’re also comfortable reviewing collections selectively and we are okay with not purchasing everything in one transaction.

Our one ask is that you be at the point where you are serious about selling your sports card collection.

While not every discussion results in a purchase, we focus on providing strong, competitive offers rather than free appraisals.

See What We BUY

What to Expect

We’ve worked with collectors for many years and have completed bulk purchases with clients time and again. As collectors ourselves, we understand that letting go of a collection can be difficult, especially when certain cards carry personal or historical value.

  • We offer cash for full sports card collections.

  • We provide on-site or travel evaluations.

  • We offer shipping options.

That’s why sellers trust and choose to work with experienced buyers like us. We make it easy and fair for you!

See Our Buy Prices

Frequently Asked Questions

If your collection includes vintage cards, complete sets, graded cards, unopened boxes, or a large number of cards, it’s usually worth having it reviewed. We’re happy to look at the details and let you know if it makes sense to move forward.

We buy full sports card collections, including large or bulk collections. In some cases, we may focus on specific cards or sets, depending on what’s included and current market demand.

Yes. For larger collections, we travel within a 350–400 mile driving radius of Columbus, Ohio. This includes much of the Midwest and surrounding states. Travel is arranged on a case-by-case basis.

Yes. For smaller items, we can provide a pre-paid FedEx shipping label. This option works well for individual cards or small groups that can be safely packaged and shipped.

We do not provide free appraisals. Our focus is on making strong, market-based purchase offers for collections where the seller is seriously considering selling.

Providing highlights of your collection, key cards or sets, an organized list (spreadsheet preferred), and an estimated value—if you have one—helps us review your collection more efficiently.

Not every discussion results in a purchase, and that’s okay. We aim to be transparent and respectful throughout the process, even if a deal doesn’t move forward.